Effects of Luminal Diameter and Deep Wall Excision

Background. Deep wall excision during directional atherectomy has been reported in one study to increase the risk of subsequent restenosis. On the other hand, we have observed that the probability of late (6-month) restenosis is reduced by maximizing postprocedure luminal diameter. Although such maximal luminal enlargement by directional atherectomy has not increased procedural complications in our experience, it might well increase the incidence of subintimal (deep wall component) recovery. We performed this study to evaluate the relative influences of luminal enlargement and deep wall component excision on postatherectomy restenosis. Methods and Results. Atherectomy resulted in a 7±15% residual stenosis with <0.5% incidence of angiographic vessel perforation. The minimal luminal diameter of each lesion was measured before and after intervention in 413 lesions, 389 (94%) of which had histological analysis of the excised specimens. Specimens were categorized by the deepest layer retrieved: type I (recovery of intima alone, n=141), type II (recovery of media, n=79), and type III (recovery of adventitia, n=65). Repeat angiographic measurement of minimal luminal diameter was available for 329 (80%no) segments 6 months after atherectomy. Compared with the 32% restenosis rate for type I excision, there was no increase in restenosis (stenosis >50%o) for type II, type III, or types 11+111 (p=0.86). Stratification by vessel characteristics also failed to show any association between restenosis and deep wail component recovery in any subgroup, including native coronary (p =0.85), left anterior descending coronary artery (p=0.70), right coronary artery (p=0.51), saphenous graft (p=0.78), or prior restenosis lesions (p=0.98). Paradoxically, the recovery of adventitia (type III excision) was associated with a lower late percent stenosis (p=0.03) and a trend toward less restenosis (p=0.11) compared with type I excisions. A multiple logistic regression model was constructed that demonstrated immediate postprocedure luminal diameter (p=0.02) to be an independent determinant of restenosis. In this model, the presence of deep wall components (types 11+III) did not adversely affect (p=0.86) restenosis, but the recovery of adventitia was associated with an independent trend toward reduced restenosis (p =0.06). Conclusions. The immediate goal of directional atherectomy should be to safely provide the largest lumen possible in order to reduce restenosis. The recovery of deep wall components does not appear to jeopardize the beneficial effect that obtaining a large immediate postprocedure lumen diameter has on reducing the incidence of late restenosis. (Circulation 1992;86:1394-1399)